In September 1968, Republican vice presidential nominee Spiro Agnew created an uproar among both Democrats and Republicans when he said that Democratic presidential nominee Hubert Humphrey was โ€œsoft on Communism.โ€

GOP presidential nominee Richard Nixon sent a babysitter, Stephen Hess, to the Agnew campaign plane to watch over the Agnew operation. Hess found that neither Agnew or his aides realized that the phrase โ€œsoft on Communismโ€ had a history.

One account of the campaign later reported, โ€œHess found to his horror that [Agnew] and most of his staff were delighted with the effect the โ€™soft on communismโ€™ speech had had. Apparently, they were infected by the Billy Rose approach to publicity: donโ€™t read it, measure it. Hess arrived just in time to stall more diatribes on the same subject. Such crowd-pleasing gambits as โ€™Communists in our midstโ€™ and โ€™lists of namesโ€™ were under consideration. At this point, it emerged that Agnew genuinely did not know that these phrases were the slogans of McCarthyism. โ€ฆ In 1953, Agnew had been an apolitical manager of a supermarket, and in the years since he hadnโ€™t bothered to find out about McCarthy.โ€

Itโ€™s appalling how often our leaders are ignorant of history and insensitive to the power of words. After the Sept. 11 tragedies in 2001, as the United States geared up for war in Afghanistan, George W. Bush said, โ€œThis crusade, this war on terrorism, is going to take awhile.โ€

In Europe, which has had more experience with terrorism than the United States and is more sophisticated in its approach to combating terror, Bushโ€™s use of the term crusade caused leaders to shudder. They want a battle between civilization and extremism, not between civilizations. In the Middle East, crusade is a reminder of Christian terrorism in the medieval periodโ€”and a synonym for extremism. Bush at the time was reportedly reading the study Warriors of God by James Reston Jr., about the third Crusade (Reston: โ€œthe crusades were among the most disgusting blots on the human recordโ€). One wonders how much Bush absorbed of the volume.

Which bring us to Donald Trump. His use of โ€œAmerica firstโ€ panders nicely to U.S. chauvinism, to those who believe the United States is exceptional. โ€œFrom this day forward, itโ€™s going to be only America first. America first,โ€ said Trump at his inauguration.

โ€œAmerica firstโ€ is a slogan used by the Ku Klux Klan (see http://tinyurl.com/zj2ta9w), by U.S. anti-Semitesโ€”including Nevadaโ€™s U.S. Sen. Pat McCarranโ€”who opposed this country fighting against Nazi Germany, by Reform Party presidential candidate and Holocaust skeptic Pat Buchanan.

Trump seems to consider himself a legitimate judge of the quality of various races and religions: โ€œWhen Mexico sends its people, theyโ€™re not sending their best,โ€ he claimed. But the quality of his own appointees is hardly testament to his judgment of people.

Because the slogan is so associated with dark forces, Trumpโ€™s use of โ€œAmerica firstโ€โ€”however popularโ€”sends a message that those forces are approved by a U.S. president. We would argue โ€œAmerica bestโ€ will never emerge from โ€œAmerica first.โ€

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *