
When I found out Ti West was going to be directing Johnny Depp in Depp’s first studio pic in eight years, that sounded interesting. When I found out it would be an adaptation of A Christmas Carol, I was intrigued even more.
While A Christmas Carol deals with Ebenezer Scrooge’s soulful transformation, it is also very much a ghost story, and Ti West has made some pretty demented horror films, including the “X” trilogy (X, Pearl and MaXXXine) and the batshit crazy House of the Devil. I was all in for a subversive, scary and, yes, batshit crazy approach to the Charles Dickens classic.
Alas, West plays it safe with Ebenezer, with Depp in the title role, producing a relatively bland take. Yes, the ghosts are a bit darker and sadder, but they aren’t very scary. Heck, John Forsythe’s ghost golfer with the ball embedded in his head in Scrooged was scarier than anything in this movie.
Filmed with a lot of handheld cameras and a dingy gray color scheme, Ebenezer feels like a low-budget indie take rather than the much-ballyhooed return to studio filmmaking for Depp. It’s often hard to make out what is going on, and it totally punts on the Ghost of Christmas Future, missing out on a great chance to do spooky things with the Grim Reaper. This ghost just sort of stands around emitting a dark gray fog, like a badly drawn cartoon character.
Depp fares OK as Ebenezer Scrooge with a surprisingly soulful, almost-sympathetic take on the character. The script makes a few changes to the story, giving a little more meaning to Scrooge’s miserly ways, and the changes are mostly welcome. You feel a little worse for the dude as he gets his comeuppance during the hauntings. Depp is a talented actor capable of portraying a lot of depth with facial expressions, and his facial muscles are in full force for this one.
Rupert Grint is solid, yet little seen, as Bob Cratchit. Ian McKellen portrays a Jacob Marley—who has a slightly deeper friendship with Scrooge than in past takes—making his demise and ghostly presence even sadder. Daisy Ridley has a couple of decent scenes as Clara, wife of Scrooge’s nephew, Fred (Sam Claflin, who is also very good).
Ultimately, West seems a little scared of himself. To get a true Ti West Christmas movie, it would have to be rated R, and nobody on the planet would greenlight such a project as a Depp comeback vehicle. There are only little hints of true horror (like Jacob Marley’s momentarily gaping jaw, the Ghost of Christmas Past’s pale white eyes, and the Ghost of Christmas Present slowly deteriorating). The film presses pause on anything truly terrifying, because it is, after all, a Christmas release that needs entire families to attend.
That said, Ebenezer isn’t really a movie for the entire family. There’s nothing in this that will be appealing to kids 10 or younger, and the older kids will probably be bummed about how it wimps out. It scored a PG-13, but I’d rate this closer to a PG. I actually witnessed a theater employee looking to enforce the rating on a kid walking into the theater by himself; the kid look perplexed.
In any case, Depp is back to work, and Ebenezer shows he can still act up a storm, even when the film isn’t really supporting him. I wouldn’t categorize this as a great Depp performance, but it’s as good as the film will allow. We’ll have to wait for his next film, Day Drinker, to see him get truly down and dirty.
Ebenezer is flat, relatively harmless and just sort of there: “Yeah, that was another version of A Christmas Carol, all right. Yawn.” It’s not the wild twist on the tale I was hoping West would deliver.
